C’mon Billy!
What happened Billy? Ashes Divide is the horrible elevator music cousin of A Perfect Circle; the notes and chords and riffs are all there but it's close to making my head explode with its asinine poppiness. The Stone has its moments, as does Denial Awaits, but compared to their A Perfect Circle counterparts - take The Outsider and Weak and Powerless as examples (both from Thirteenth Step) they're.. well, weak and powerless indeed.
Pardon that pun, Billy, but I know you can do better. Mer De Noms and Thirteenth Step is right up there with the best of them, fantastic sound and production, some incredible songwriting and performances. It feels as if all the band members are there, pulling in their own direction and yet making a perfect whole, the way a good band album should sound. Ashes Divide feels like it's pulling nowhere.
Ashes Divide reminds me of another Billy's recent solo efforts and.. I'm not sure I dare mention the name.. Zwan. I feel dirty now.
Speaking of The Outsider, whoa, what an incredibly worked-through song - the drums and syncopations, yummy layered guitars that never get muddy, a band that works in amazing sync with the vocals when that extra power is needed and a great ending: no repeats or fadeouts, just a kick ass bridge and build-up before one last round and out with a bang!
Get back on your horse, Billy, get the guys back together, set those amps to 11 and go for it.
